Siraj Hussain Fathi عربي

Merely a Medical Error?!

Siraj Hussain Fathi13 February 2011Al-Madina newspaper

When any Muslim commits a sin and Allah conceals it for him, the door of repentance is open to him until the Day of Resurrection. When one of us wrongs his family or his friend, he may express regret and apologize and be forgiven, and seeking forgiveness is one of the doors of mercy that never close. Some mistakes and sins are wiped away by repentance, seeking forgiveness and asking pardon of the Creator, glory be to Him, the Exalted, and by apologizing to people if the wrong was done against them. But what are known as medical errors may be wiped away by no repentance and erased by no apology. In the field of medicine in general, and in our government and private hospitals alike, we have a huge number of them. Some doctors or officials in this field may think they can be passed over with a word of apology or a letter of regret, but how can that be accepted, especially if the case clearly shows a kind of negligence and carelessness with people's lives, or ignorance of the basics of the profession altogether, or sometimes deliberate action? I do not think it easy to consider this within the scope of errors that can be forgiven or overlooked, especially if the result is a death, a congenital defect, or a chronic or serious illness?

Anyone who follows what is published in the press and broadcast through other media, radio, television, internet sites and mobile messages, not to mention people's talk and the news they pass among themselves about what happens in the corridors of hospitals, medical centres and clinics and the so-called medical errors committed there, will see that all of this is evidence of some defect, or a compound set of defects, in these places that are supposed to be trustworthy guardians of people's health, bodies and lives, not a cause of their death or disability, in addition to the exorbitant financial losses that weigh down their shoulders. Can this be considered merely medical errors?

How can we believe that, when on the ground there are very long lists of examples? When a newborn baby girl is cleaned and washed with boiling water in a luxurious, modern hospital, what can the result be? And when the hospital owner is content to apologize and say he will terminate the contract of the nurse who committed that folly, can this be considered merely a medical error?

And when a nurse does not know how to insert a needle in its place to draw blood or to connect a drip, or a quantity of blood leaks from it onto the floor of the room in the emergency department of a large government hospital, can this be merely a medical error, or is it compound ignorance on the part of the nurse, of whoever issued the decision to appoint her, and of whoever contracted her to work in our country?

And when a surgeon sets about performing an abdominal operation for the third time, doing his utmost to convince the patient's father of its necessity, when not even one week has passed since the second operation, which was itself performed only one week after the first, can this be considered merely a medical error, or is it organized crime hiding under the cover of medicine, and contempt for people's lives, money and nerves, so long as there is no one to hold anyone to account and no one to oversee..!!?

This article was first published in Al-Madina newspaper. Read it on the original site