Siraj Hussain Fathi عربي

Literary Clubs and Thinking Outside the Box

Siraj Hussain Fathi12 November 2011Al-Madina newspaper

Decades ago, when the pioneers of the literary movement in our country - may Allah have mercy on them, living and dead - strove and arrived at the idea of launching literary clubs, they had good reason for their endeavour, since the resources of knowledge and culture were not vast and limitless as they are today; there was nothing but public or private libraries, or some local and Arab literary and cultural newspapers and magazines in general, and Egyptian ones in particular, some of which are still struggling to survive. Nor were the means of local society at that time sufficient to help it provide broader fields and opportunities to meet the needs of lovers of thought and culture. So the literary clubs were their refuge and their means for cross-fertilizing ideas, exchanging opinions and spreading awareness among members of society, common and elite alike. In “ the Blessed Valley Circle “ (Usrat al-Wadi al-Mubarak) in Madinah al-Munawwarah we have the best model of this trend, and in the Al-Wahda Literary and Cultural Club another model, for it was a wide space for free debate and refined scholarly and cultural dialogue.

Today, after that period has passed, with the dominance of means of communication that are broader, faster, stronger and freer, and the availability of great capabilities for spreading culture and knowledge via the internet and satellite channels, let us ask how useful the literary clubs are in their traditional form - in shape, substance and management - with full respect and esteem for all. Do they have a real necessity and great importance as they did in those decades? Must the lover of knowledge leave his home and head to the literary club in his city to attend or listen to a lecture, or to watch an argument between parties quarrelling over nothing - sometimes - and fanatically attached to their own thought and orientation most of the time? The greater calamity is the absence of an audience large enough to match the arrangements, preparations and coordination, which has become well known about most of the clubs' events. Perhaps the most realistic reason is the modern means of communication and knowledge that have erased geographic and intellectual borders and given any individual the chance to follow or watch cultural and scholarly activities and events held anywhere in the world while he is at home, without the trouble of looking for a parking space for his car or getting caught in traffic jams. Indeed, he enjoys living his private life away from others' eyes, free to eat, drink and dress as he likes while following the event. In addition, following by satellite allows the individual to hear points of view, ideas and opinions that might be difficult to raise in our traditional literary clubs, which live inside a closed box that they are mostly not allowed to leave except within the narrowest limits!!

It seems that insisting on the continuation of the literary clubs in their traditional formula, and keeping them as they are despite all the changes that have surrounded us on every side, may be a grave error against literature and men of letters, thought and thinkers, culture and intellectuals, and the whole of society. Proposals have been put forward as an alternative to the clubs: transforming them into comprehensive cultural and civilizational centres that embrace all people with talents, hobbies and literary and other inclinations, so that the events they offer are varied and not confined to one particular kind and a limited group. Perhaps the statements of the Minister of Culture and Information, Dr. Abdulaziz Khoja, contain something pointing to this wish; may it come true at his hands, he who has a soaring spirit, a big heart and a broad mind.

This article was first published in Al-Madina newspaper. Read it on the original site