Siraj Hussain Fathi عربي

Dialogues Without Purpose

Siraj Hussain Fathi31 July 2010Al-Madina newspaper

Many years have now passed of the dialogue and discussion programmes presented on Arab satellite channels, famous and not so famous, which have had, and will have, no positive result for either the parties to the dialogue or those who follow them. This confirms that their aim (all or most of the programmes) was merely to fill the gaps in those channels' schedules and to let most of the participants flex their muscles, which shows that their sole goal is "dialogue for the sake of dialogue", or more correctly "argument for the sake of argument", not arriving at the truth and getting rid of intellectual, doctrinal or even political errors and deviations..!

And if this is the state of the programmes on the satellite channels, the state of what goes on, and has gone on, in most of the dialogues and conferences held at the local or international level, from which it was hoped that many intellectual, religious and political dilemmas would be untangled among the peoples of Arab societies and states, their institutions, their thinkers and their religious figures, is no better than that of the satellite programmes. Most of the participating parties (except those on whom my Lord has mercy) did not carry within them the intention of arriving at the truth; rather, some had hidden intentions and others had open ones, not to mention that there was no agreement among the participants to achieve real accord. Each party clings to its opinion and has not the slightest degree of flexibility or desire to abandon the ideas it holds, even when their faults, errors and dangers have been exposed..!

If the situation continues as it is today, no wrong situation will change, no flaw will be repaired and no defects will be eliminated, because the real goal, which is to seek the truth with a firm and sincere desire to arrive at what is right, and which should be agreed upon among the participants in advance, is not present at all, or is present only to a very small degree. Were it present in reality, many intellectual, political and religious problems and tensions would vanish from existence.

True, difference is a divine law among human beings, but this does not mean that a person should cling to any idea or principle even when its ills and errors have become apparent, especially if the one who has made the effort to clarify the facts and explain the aspects of the issue from its many angles is a person of knowledge or of deep experience and understanding, known for his truthfulness and his distance from blind fanaticism, enmity and hatred, whose aim is to spread goodness, love and harmony among the members of one society, one faith and one state..!

This article was first published in Al-Madina newspaper. Read it on the original site