Our Missing Dialogue!
“Narrow-mindedness and refusing to accept the other opinion,” even when it comes from a dear friend, a relative or a work colleague, let alone others, and especially within the walls of homes - this is something I have noticed in myself and in many people I know, among them academics, journalists and teachers. It was confirmed to me by the dialogues among members of some of the WhatsApp and Telegram groups in which I take part, some of which I supervise, where some could not bear others, so they roared, thundered and foamed, and then left the group - and perhaps every group they had been hosted in!
I wonder how true this picture is, and whether it depicts our state? If so, can it be adjusted and reformed? And how? I put this issue to my visitors on my Facebook page and in WhatsApp groups, and some dear friends commented on it, among them Mr. Osama Usailan, who said:
“I have entered into a great many discussions - praise be to Allah - and the one who got angry, roared and left was the other party. We must train ourselves to accept the other opinion; the right always belongs to whoever relies on evidence. But time and nerves affect participants, and some are excused for withdrawing because of the sheer number of discussions, groups and so on.”
As for Mr. Fayez Sulaihim, he says: My view is that our actions are nothing but reactions to our actions!! I don't mean to be facetious; it is because we lack the etiquette of dialogue. This is our state: we strip away the right to expression.. we confiscate what is right.. we speak in the role of the father and belittle the other.. we claim experience and good judgment. So what do you expect of us but that we conduct dialogue with the same disastrous methodology, and the quarrels of discussions are born.. I am certain that many do not intend it and do not even think they are doing it at all, but there is a set of terms dominating society's dialogues at the expense of terms which, if they returned, would bring back the etiquette of dialogue.
“Some” has disappeared and “all” has taken its place.. the phrase “I may be wrong” has disappeared, and the phrase “I understand better than you” has taken its place; the analogies here are many and there is no room to list them. There remains another matter, and it is more important: we no longer accord people their proper standing, so we address the father, the teacher and the elder in the same way we address the son...”
As for Prof. Dr. Khalid Hamid al-Hazmi, he believes that one of the causes is that everyone believes the truth is on his side and sees himself as understanding more than others. Then comes the pivotal question: “Why this feeling?” Here it may be said that among the causes, in brief, are the influence of the social environment; our upbringing, which has not rid us of that conceit; our conflicting sources of knowledge - and I do not say our scholarly sources; and cultural background and inclinations, which play a large role in directing thought. The remedy, in brief: the practical exercise of discussion in our schools, from which we must learn how to discuss knowledge. This requires training the teacher first; then the importance of awareness that information is not confined to particular people and never goes beyond them, except in matters of specialization; the importance of awareness of exchanging ideas and the etiquette of listening and discussion; and the importance of grasping the value of humility and practising it in all aspects of life, including humility in possessing knowledge. Truly a very important and broad subject; thank you for raising it, and may Allah make you of benefit.
I wonder: after numerous sessions of the National Dialogue and other events, courses and lectures on dialogue, have we mastered it and become able to conduct it competently among ourselves? And can pioneering successes be achieved that help us continue the process of positively building our society, for the good of coming generations?
Read also
- The Municipality as an Educational Institution 8 August 2014
- ISIS and Its Sisters!! 5 September 2014
- Yes.. We Must Rejoice 1 August 2014
- The Kaaba in My Heart 12 September 2014
- Palestine Is the Cause.. Not Gaza 25 July 2014