A Homeland Is Not Built on Courtesies
The "homeland" is not merely the soil we live on, nor the people who walk upon it, nor even the air we breathe. It is all of that and greater than all of that. It is the faith that fills hearts and bears the fruit of security and safety for soul and body alike; it is the heritage that forms a strong background and a safety valve of peace and goodness for the present and the future, in this world and the Hereafter; it is the gains that its sincere sons strive to build and to raise, and through which they rise ever towards the better; it is every good that grows in the depths and spreads into the space around us; it is the homeland of religion, people and soil. If dialogue between certain parties representing intellectual or doctrinal currents tries to entrench the concept of the homeland and patriotism in a calm manner, free of agitation and tension, that is good, but only up to a point, even though the aim is to contain the tensions arising from positions and views in whose origin the past history played a part and which the contemporary present sometimes plays a part in inflaming. It is therefore difficult to achieve real balance, to root rationality and openness to the other, without absolute and genuine transparency, and without a deep frankness that uproots the rot of history and the transgressions of the present, so as to begin pages that are spotless, as far as possible, free of impurities and doctrinal and intellectual spasms; otherwise any attempt that does not take this path writes its own failure. The approach of courtesies, of overlooking the intellectual and doctrinal errors of history or the present without discussing them rationally, with firm knowledge and absolute transparency, will not be able to build the homeland nor entrench belonging and loyalty to it, to its people and to its creed. Courtesies are no more than a form of the taqiyya known among some sects, and here it has become practised by both sides; it will not lay a single brick in building the homeland, and may instead be a poisoned dagger thrust into the side of every citizen, not the homeland alone. Therefore whoever wishes to carry the banner of unifying the word, closing ranks and eradicating the seeds of strife, of whatever kind, must know the extent of the risk, the effort and the weight of responsibility involved in achieving the desired goals of this truly dangerous and important project. I wrote these lines as a personal view (and I hope it is correct to the greatest possible extent) on the dialogue presented by the well-known media figure Dr. Abdulaziz Qasim, in which he hosted Dr. Sheikh Saad al-Buraik and Sheikh Hasan al-Saffar. It was a fine dialogue, but the presenter tried to steer clear of the quarrels that occur on talk programmes on other channels; yet this does not excuse him from providing enough room for transparency, frankness and time to enable both parties to speak and express the issues clearly and freely, and then to agree on strong, solid foundations on the most dangerous issue from which the people and the country suffer. And because the time allotted to television programmes is in any case not enough for sensitive discussions, the National Dialogue Center is the best arena for them. The project began at its first meeting, but it later became preoccupied with partial administrative and intellectual issues not as serious as this one. If only the Center would return to where it began, so that real national dialogue between the parties of intellectual, doctrinal and political difference may be activated, and the strong bricks then laid in their place in the building of our precious homeland.
Read also
- The Hidden Column 4 June 2010
- Monopoly Is Our Problem 4 June 2010
- Are We a Backward People? 4 June 2010
- O Official, You Are Accountable 4 June 2010
- Democracy: Myth or Reality? 4 June 2010