Siraj Hussain Fathi عربي

“Education”: Public and Private

Siraj Hussain Fathi25 January 2013Al-Madina newspaper

Is it not cause for astonishment, and for asking why, that the sons and daughters of some education officials, senior government officials and prominent figures in society are enrolled in private schools?!

We may not be surprised to hear an education official justify his children's presence in these schools by the poor standard of education in many public schools. Sheikh Saleh Kamel has repeated his call to capital owners to invest in education, as it is better for them and for society. It is a good call whose aim, apparently, is to raise the standard of education in our country, along with the prospect of high returns on that investment. One sign of response to and fulfilment of this call may be proof of its feasibility, particularly the profit and financial return for investors. But does the educational and academic return rise in step? It is important to pause and ask about this point, because it touches on how far students benefit from enrolling in private educational institutions compared with public ones. Have private-sector educational institutions truly fulfilled their role in raising the level of their students and placing them on the “real” lists of excellence above their peers in public institutions, or is what goes on under the table different from what is put on top of it?!

It is necessary to pause and reflect first on the state of public schools and the poor level of performance in most of them (as is said) in every respect: equipment, genuinely well-qualified human resources, and the availability of facilities and budgets that go beyond mere staff salaries to stirring the often stagnant waters. This draws attention and prompts a whole queue of question marks. Is the problem the weakness of the operating budget, especially for activities, and the availability of educational facilities such as laboratories and modern technical equipment? Or have we been preoccupied with side issues and formalities in which time, effort and money are lost without our seeing strong effects that play a positive role in entrenching deep, positive change in the course of public educational institutions? Is it reasonable that no one has discovered the causes of the defect and the weak performance of many of these institutions, or is everything known but there is no one who wants to take the initiative to reform and change the course of this deadly routine work?!

Many employees of the Ministry of Education may disagree with me for merely raising these questions, and many may consider what I have done unacceptable. But am I not right in what I have presented, or am I talking about imaginary and unreal things? Some may accuse me of not living in the real world, and they may cite as evidence the reports they submit to the responsible authorities on how the train of education runs with full force and high quality, and students' results are, in their view, the best witness to good performance; so they consider these questions to have no place at all. But were it not that I live in the field, indeed have spent my entire working life in education as student, teacher and official, then the suffering I and others have gone through, and what I hear and read through the media, would confirm the soundness of my position. I say to them: enough of embellishing the facts. Some of them may be among those who have not realized that times have changed, that we now have an “Anti-Corruption Authority”, and that their turn may come to be questioned about the sincerity of their efforts and the accuracy of the reports they submit, which are no more than decorated, coloured files furnished with charts and pictures showing the range of activities and events carried out, and which do not represent the reality that many of our schools live..!!

This article was first published in Al-Madina newspaper. Read it on the original site